Scoring genre clarity...

I commissioned some pigeons 2 capsule

I commissioned some pigeons 2

I paid more artists to hide pigeons and bread in 15 more pieces of artwork. Can you find them all? Warning: Relaxing.

$3.991 user reviews
Hidden ObjectFamily FriendlyHand-drawn
Follow the funNov 21, 2025

I commissioned some pigeons 2 scores 67/100 — better than 21% of Hidden Object capsules (n=1,405).

1 user reviews · $3.99 · Released Nov 21, 2025 · By Follow the fun

Explore:Hidden Object capsulesFamily Friendly capsulesHand-drawn capsulesSteam page optimisationCapsule design best practices

Quick text summary

I commissioned some pigeons 2 scored 67/100 on Steam Analyzer — Solid for a Hidden Object capsule. Top priority fix: [uniqueness_polish] Integrate a simple, iconic pigeon character or silhouette into the title area to immediately communicate the core theme and differentiate from generic casual games.

Capsule scores by dimension

  • Genre Clarity: 7/10 — Casual indie puzzle vibe clear. The playful, hand-drawn art style and title treatment immediately signal a casual, lighthearted indie game rather than action or narrative-heavy work. The whimsical typography and soft pastel background reinforce the relaxing, approachable tone described in the game summary. At tiny size, the colorful title and friendly aesthetic still read as casual indie rather than confusion with other genres.
  • Title Readability: 8/10 — Bold title readable at small sizes. The large, high-contrast white outline text with blue and purple fill reads clearly even at small capsule sizes, and the '2' emphasis provides quick recognition of the sequel. The title sits on a controlled neutral background rather than competing texture, allowing strong legibility across all viewing conditions. At tiny size, the text holds together well, though some fine detail in letter forms becomes softer.
  • Contrast & Color: 7/10 — Warm neutral palette with adequate separation. The soft peachy-tan background provides moderate value contrast against the white-outlined text and purple '2' accent, creating reasonable pop against Steam's dark UI. The light tones of the title separate cleanly from the background in both color and value, though the overall warmth feels somewhat muted rather than vibrant. At tiny size, the contrast holds adequately for text clarity, but the background lacks punchy visual differentiation.
  • Uniqueness & Polish: 6/10 — Competent craft, generic casual aesthetic. The capsule demonstrates solid execution with clean typography, consistent outline treatment, and a professional finish, but the soft pastel background and cheerful indie style align closely with many current casual game capsules rather than standing out distinctly. While the title treatment is well-executed, the overall visual strategy relies on familiar indie game presentation cues without a strong hook or memorable visual identity unique to pigeons or the specific concept. The design is pleasant and competent but does not convey the core mechanic (finding hidden pigeons) through visual storytelling.
  • Brand Consistency: 5/10 — Generic indie style, lacks iconic elements. The capsule uses a standard casual indie palette and typography approach without establishing a memorable brand identity specific to the 'I Commissioned Some Pigeons' franchise; there are no visible pigeon characters, signature motifs, or distinctive visual symbols that would carry across store screenshots and create recognition. The soft, friendly aesthetic is internally consistent but does not leverage or establish any iconic brand cues that differentiate this title from dozens of similar indie games. Without access to screenshot cohesion, the capsule alone reads as generically indie rather than distinctly pigeon-focused.
  • Composition: 7/10 — Clear centered title, balanced layout. The title dominates the center with strong visual hierarchy, the '2' sits appropriately to the right as a supporting emphasis, and the uniform pastel background provides a stable, uncluttered foundation. The layout balances well across full, small, and tiny sizes with no awkward cropping risk or edge-hugging issues. The composition is straightforward and functional, though it lacks layered depth or focal point intrigue that would elevate the overall visual interest.

What works

  • Title legibility at scale. Bold white outline and color fill hold clarity from full size down to tiny thumbnail without collapse or mudding.
  • Clean, uncluttered layout. Centered composition with balanced negative space avoids visual noise and supports quick recognition during fast scrolling.
  • Consistent outline treatment. Professionalism is evident in the refined typography with clean strokes and precise letter spacing throughout the title.

What hurts the capsule

  • Generic casual game aesthetic. The soft pastel palette and friendly indie styling blend with dozens of similar casual titles without distinctive visual personality.
  • No pigeon or game concept visuals. The capsule does not show or hint at the core mechanic (finding hidden pigeons) through any visual element, missing an opportunity for thematic differentiation.
  • Lacks memorable brand identity cues. No iconic character, color signature, or symbolic motif that would carry brand recognition across multiple store touchpoints or sequels.
  • Muted background contrast. The warm peachy-tan background provides adequate but not punchy separation against the dark Steam UI, reducing visual impact in competitive shelf display.

Priority fixes

  1. [uniqueness_polish] Integrate a simple, iconic pigeon character or silhouette into the title area to immediately communicate the core theme and differentiate from generic casual games.
  2. [contrast_color] Increase saturation or shift the background toward a richer, more distinct hue that creates stronger visual pop against the #1b2838 Steam background.
  3. [brand_consistency] Establish and embed a visual signature (distinctive palette, recurring character, or motif) that will be recognizable across all 15 commissioned artwork screenshots.
  4. [composition] Add subtle background texture or layered visual elements that hint at the hidden-object puzzle mechanic without cluttering the clean title hierarchy.

Store copy priority fixes

  1. [uniqueness] Add a sentence in the short description or key features that explicitly states what is new or different in this sequel (e.g., "New restoration mechanic lets you replay artworks with fewer objects hidden" or "Harder difficulty and new artistic themes" to differentiate from the first game).
  2. [feature_communication] Promote the restoration/replayability mechanic to the main feature list with a clear one-liner explaining how it increases replay value (e.g., "Randomly restore objects to paintings and find them again for a harder challenge").
  3. [hook_strength] Consider adding one sentence in the detailed description that speaks to why a player should care about this specific game now (e.g., a note on new art styles, artist names, or the appeal of the fantasy setting) to strengthen audience connection beyond "more of the same."
  4. [tone_match] Maintain the conversational tone by adding a brief creative note about the artworks or pigeons themselves (e.g., "Each painting hides pigeons in increasingly tricky spots") rather than relying solely on bullet-point mechanics.

Related guides

Steam app ID: 3728050 · Tags: Hidden Object, Family Friendly, Hand-drawn, Relaxing, Puzzle